Salmon is often seen as a healthy, sustainable choice, packed with omega-3s and perfect for everything from sushi to Sunday dinners. But when that salmon comes from a farm rather than the wild, things get complicated. Behind the appealing pink fillets lies a mess of health concerns, environmental damage, and questionable fish welfare. Let’s dive into what the science says about farmed salmon - how it affects us, the planet, and the fish themselves.

What’s Actually in Farmed Salmon?

Most people eat salmon thinking it's one of the healthiest choices at the fish counter. That’s true for wild-caught varieties, but farmed salmon is a different story.

Contaminants You Didn’t Sign Up For

Farmed salmon contain higher levels of pollutants than their wild cousins. Researchers have found polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) and dioxins - industrial toxins linked to cancer, immune system problems, and developmental issues in children - lurking in these fish. These substances accumulate in their bodies through the feed they eat, which often includes ground-up fish, soy protein, and synthetic additives.

Heavy metals like mercury and lead also turn up in farmed salmon. While the levels might not be dangerously high in a single serving, frequent consumption raises concerns. Mercury in particular can have neurological effects, especially in pregnant women and young children.

Antibiotics & Chemical Residues

Farmed fish are kept in dense enclosures, which makes disease outbreaks common. To prevent mass die-offs, fish farmers often turn to antibiotics. This isn’t just an issue for the salmon - it contributes to antibiotic resistance in humans, making it harder for us to fight off bacterial infections.

Then there are the pesticides used to control sea lice, a parasite that thrives in fish farms. Some of these chemicals have been linked to health issues in humans, but the biggest problem is their impact on the surrounding ecosystem.

Nutritional Trade-Offs

Salmon is famous for its omega-3 fatty acids, but farmed salmon doesn’t quite measure up to the wild variety. Their feed is designed to fatten them up quickly, which leads to higher overall fat content, but a less ideal balance of omega-3s to omega-6s. Since excessive omega-6 consumption has been linked to inflammation and heart disease, this shift in fatty acid composition is something to think about.

The Environmental Cost of Salmon Farming

Fish farms don’t just affect the fish inside them. They have a massive impact on the surrounding waters, wild fish populations, and marine ecosystems.

Pollution Below the Surface

Salmon farming is like keeping thousands of fish in a floating feedlot. All their waste - along with uneaten food and chemical residues - ends up in the ocean, sinking to the seabed or drifting with the currents. This overloads the local ecosystem with nutrients, triggering algal blooms that deplete oxygen levels and suffocate marine life.

The problem isn’t just excess waste. The antibiotics and pesticides used in salmon farms don’t stay put. They spread through the water, affecting wild fish and even shellfish like mussels and oysters, which absorb contaminants from their environment.

Wild Salmon in Trouble

Farmed salmon don’t always stay where they’re supposed to. Thousands escape each year, mixing with wild populations and creating problems. They breed with wild salmon, weakening genetic diversity and reducing their ability to survive in the wild.

Escaped farmed salmon also compete with wild salmon for food and territory. Since they’ve been bred for rapid growth rather than survival, they often end up at a disadvantage - but not before disrupting local ecosystems.

The Sea Lice Epidemic

One of the biggest issues with salmon farms is their role in spreading sea lice, parasites that attach to fish and feed on their skin. In a crowded fish farm, sea lice multiply quickly, latching onto both farmed and wild fish. Young wild salmon are especially vulnerable, often dying before they have a chance to mature.

Attempts to control sea lice have led to heavy pesticide use, but these chemicals harm other marine species too. Some have even been shown to kill shrimp and other crustaceans, further disrupting ocean food chains.

Life Inside a Salmon Farm: The Welfare Problem

If you care about ethical food production, farmed salmon presents some serious challenges. Their entire existence is dictated by efficiency - maximising growth while minimising costs. That often means crowded, stressful conditions that compromise their health and welfare.

Overcrowding & Stress

Imagine being packed into a tight space with thousands of others, with no room to move freely. That’s the reality for farmed salmon. Overcrowding leads to stress, which weakens their immune systems and makes them more prone to disease. It also triggers aggressive behaviour, including fin nipping and injuries from collisions.

High stocking densities also mean poor water quality. Oxygen levels drop, waste accumulates, and fish struggle to breathe. Some farms try to aerate the water, but it’s a Band-Aid solution to a much bigger problem.

High Mortality Rates

Salmon farming has alarmingly high mortality rates. Many fish never make it to harvest due to disease, stress, or handling injuries. Even among those that survive, deformities are common. Rapid growth, combined with artificial diets, often leads to skeletal issues and muscle abnormalities.

Handling practices add to the problem. Fish are frequently moved between tanks or farms, which increases stress and can cause physical injuries. Vaccination processes - where fish are manually injected - are another stressor. While necessary to prevent disease, it’s another indication of how unnatural the farming environment is.

Artificial Diets & Health Issues

Wild salmon eat a natural diet rich in small fish, krill, and other marine organisms. Farmed salmon, on the other hand, get processed feed. While some farms still use fishmeal, many have switched to plant-based alternatives like soy and corn protein to cut costs.

The problem? Salmon aren’t meant to eat plants. Their digestive systems struggle with soy-based diets, leading to inflammation and other health issues. Some farms are experimenting with insect-based feeds, which might be a more natural alternative, but the industry has a long way to go before achieving a truly sustainable solution.

Is There a Better Way?

Given all these issues, it’s fair to ask whether farmed salmon can ever be truly sustainable or ethical. Some farms are trying to improve conditions - reducing antibiotic use, experimenting with more natural feeds, and even developing land-based systems that eliminate ocean pollution. But large-scale change is slow, and demand for cheap salmon keeps driving intensive farming practices.

For consumers, the best option is to be selective. Look for responsibly farmed salmon certified by organisations like the Aquaculture Stewardship Council (ASC) or opt for wild-caught salmon where possible. If you eat fish regularly, diversifying your choices - trying smaller, more sustainable fish like sardines or anchovies - can also help reduce reliance on farmed salmon.

Ultimately, the industry needs serious reform. The health concerns, environmental damage, and ethical issues surrounding farmed salmon aren’t going away anytime soon. Until better solutions are widespread, it’s worth questioning whether the convenience of readily available salmon is really worth the cost.

References:

  1. Bearth, A., & Siegrist, M. (2024). Sea lice management in marine-based salmon farming. Aquaculture, Elsevier.
  2. Ortega-Villaizan, MDM et al. (2024). Immunonutrition as an experimental approach to enhance fish robustness. Frontiers in Immunology.
  3. Ashrafi, R., et al. (2024). Heterogeneity of the rearing environment enhances microbial diversity in farming. Animal Microbiome, Springer.
  4. Zhou, X., et al. (2024). Impact of salmon farming on wild species and environment. Aquaculture, Elsevier.
  5. Vidigal, B.N. (2024). Environmental impacts of salmon aquaculture. University of Queensland.
  6. Seibel, H. (2024). Welfare and stress in salmonids. German National Library.
  7. Turner, S.M. (2024). Cellulose Nanomaterials as a Vaccine System for Aquaculture. University of Maine.
  8. Kokkali, M. (2024). Metabolic pathways and physiological functions of trace minerals in salmon. University of Bergen.